How to choose a softball glove

Why the glove matters

New players often blame themselves when they drop a ball, when the real problem is a glove that does not close or a hand that is sliding around inside. Think about what a new player experiences on the field: a ball is coming, she has a second to react, and she needs to catch it with a piece of equipment she barely knows. A glove that is a friend rather than a fight makes that moment less stressful. A glove is the one piece of softball equipment a player uses on every play. A glove that fits and feels right helps a new player catch with confidence, which makes the whole game more fun. A glove that is too big, too stiff or built for the wrong position makes catching harder and can discourage a new player. You do not need the most expensive glove. You need a good fit and a good match for the position. The equipment checklist lists everything else a player needs.

Softball glove or baseball glove?

Parents often ask whether a hand-me-down baseball glove will work. For a first season of casual play it often can, especially if the player is still figuring out whether she likes the sport. Softball is played with a larger ball than baseball, and softball gloves are generally made with that ball in mind. Many players use gloves labeled for softball, especially in fastpitch. A glove marked for baseball may work for casual catch, but check the label and ask your coach what they prefer. See softball vs baseball differences for more on how the two games compare.

How a glove should fit

Fit is the single most important factor, and it is easy to check at home or in a store. Look for these signs:

• Snug, not tight. The hand should reach the fingers without sliding around, and the player should be able to squeeze the glove closed with ease.
• Not too big. A glove too large for the player is hard to control and slow to close. Youth gloves are made smaller for a reason.
• Comfortable wrist and strap. The adjustable closure should hold the glove on without pinching.
• Try before you buy when possible. Have your child put it on, squeeze it, and catch a few soft throws in the store or at home.

Sizes are measured differently by brand, and fit varies by player, so do not rely on age or a size chart alone. A quick test at home: have your child catch a few gentle tosses and watch whether the ball stays in the pocket and whether she can close the glove without using two hands.

Choosing by position

Pitchers often prefer a closed web so the batter cannot see the ball and grip. First base and catcher mitts are specialty items that most players buy only once they commit to the position. A beginner who has not picked a position can start with an all-purpose glove and change later. See softball positions explained for what each position does.

Leather, synthetic and the break-in

Gloves are made from different materials, and each has trade-offs for a young player. Here is what to know:

• Leather gloves are durable and mold to the hand over time, but they feel stiff at first.
• Synthetic or softer-leather gloves are often easier for younger players to close right away.
• Breaking in means making a stiff glove flexible by using it. Playing catch is the best way. Many players also use a glove conditioner made for gloves, following the label. Avoid shortcuts that sound extreme, such as soaking in water or baking, since they can damage the glove.

Taking care of a glove

A glove that is cared for lasts longer and plays better. Good habits take only a few minutes and are easy to build into the routine of packing a bag.

• Store it in a dry place at room temperature, not in a hot car or damp bag.
• Put a ball in the pocket and secure it during storage so the pocket keeps its shape.
• Wipe off dirt and let a damp glove air dry naturally.
• Mark it with the player's name so it does not get lost at the field.
• Do not sit or stand on it, and do not leave it on the ground in the dugout where it can be stepped on.

Common mistakes

Most glove problems come from a handful of avoidable choices. Watch for these:

• Buying a big glove for the child to grow into.
• Choosing by looks or brand rather than fit.
• Skipping the break-in and expecting a stiff glove to work on day one.
• Letting the glove sit under a pile of gear.
• Buying left- or right-hand versions without checking. A glove goes on the hand she does not throw with.

What to ask your coach

Coaches see many gloves every season and can quickly tell whether one is too stiff, too big or poorly suited to the position. Ask whether your team has a preference for gloves, whether position-specific gloves are expected at this age, and whether the league has any rules on glove color or style. Many youth coaches are happy to look at a glove and tell you whether it fits well.

Sources and further reading

1. What Parents, Local Leagues Need to Know About Equipping a Little Leaguer Little League International
2. Baseball and Softball HealthyChildren.org (American Academy of Pediatrics)

Links open in a new tab. Quotations are short excerpts, included with attribution for commentary. BlackForge Sports is not affiliated with or endorsed by the people or organizations named.

Frequently asked questions

How should a softball glove fit?

Snug but not tight, with the fingers reaching the end of the glove and enough control to close it easily.

Is a softball glove different from a baseball glove?

Softball gloves are generally made for the larger ball, though some players use either. Check the label and ask your coach.

How do you break in a softball glove?

Use it. Playing catch is the best method, with a glove conditioner made for gloves if you like. Avoid shortcuts like baking or soaking.

Should my child buy a glove to grow into?

Usually not. A glove that is too big is hard to control, which makes catching harder.

Does my child need a position-specific glove?

Not at first. A beginner can start with an all-purpose glove and switch when she settles on a position.